Ten years after the UK embarked on a hasty public vote that polarised the nation and unleashed turmoil, a warning is issued from across the Irish Sea: it could happen again.
Authorities and electorate drifted into Brexit and the identical may happen with a referendum on a unified Ireland, triggering disturbances for which no one is prepared.
That is the message from two leading journalists from either side of the Irish border who have teamed up to examine the advantages and disadvantages of Northern Ireland departing the UK to create a new state with the Republic of Ireland.
Political Structures Ill-Equipped
The author and columnist and The Northern Ireland editor, have determined that the political establishments in Ireland and Britain are woefully ill-prepared for a potentially fraught and seismic referendum.
"The crucial insight of Brexit has gone unabsorbed, which is that stuff can come out of the blue and can gain traction rapidly," the commentator remarked. "It is my view that the institutional structure of our archipelago remains very unstable."
New Title Intends to Stir Debate
The pair have studied the political, financial and cultural arguments for any constitutional change in a volume, The Case For and Against Unification, released by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.
They seek to stir debate on the issue with a roadshow of lectures that will take them to Westminster early next month.
"What concerns all parties, or should haunt all involved, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," commented O’Toole.
"We do not want a referendum on a binary, unclear proposal whose results have not been clarified because then you land with an extraordinarily polarised community where the losing side are unable to accept losing and the victorious side lack clarity quite what it is that they have achieved."
Constitutional Provision
Under the peace accord, the Northern Ireland secretary of state is obliged to schedule a referendum on Irish unification if it seems probable that a majority would approve.
Sinn Féin and other pro-unification groups claim this point is looming, and a non-profit named Ireland’s Future has garnered backing, but authorities in Dublin and London and unionists play down the likelihood, making it uncertain when or if there might be a national vote.
Lack of Informed Dialogue
Partisan language for and against unification has obscured the lack of serious debate, said McBride.
"People tend to be supportive or opposed the concept but the concrete planning which might go beyond that to make it possible is mostly absent. Much has taken place in scholarly circles but hardly any government figures or campaigners seek to involve themselves with even the fundamentals. To illustrate, what type of nation would you want? Unitary? Federal?"
Volume's Strategy
In the volume, neither author endorses unity or the status quo. They writes two pieces that strive for neutrality in presenting the case for a united Ireland and the argument opposing it, marshalling financial and social statistics, historical precedents and governmental frameworks.
Discussions range over national emblems, duties, healthcare systems, pensions, sovereign debt obligations and the danger of loyalist violence. The aim is to enlighten and encourage conversation.
"There is significant curiosity in the topic but there has not yet occurred a debate," said O’Toole. "Dialogue suggests an acknowledgement of the notion that there might be reasonable perspectives on either side."
Simultaneous Plebiscites
A referendum in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where voters say they support unity but reject paying higher taxes or implementing a different emblem to recognise unionists' UK heritage.
"Policymakers in Ireland should determine what the proposal from nationalist groups is beyond just stating: 'We desire a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," remarked O’Toole.
Probability of Referendum
McBride thinks a referendum in his generation is probable and that it may take place suddenly. "You could have just a mad or a ill-advised or a incompetent government minister who says: 'Let us proceed and settle the matter.'"
Both pro-unification advocates and unionists have reasonable, justified perspectives, he commented. "One side will prevail in this matter and the other side will eventually lose but both parties has has important lessons to acquire from the alternative arguments."
Appeal for Wider Debate
Westminster needed to participate in the dialogue, said O’Toole. "This is about Britain. It is a British issue as much as it is an Irish issue."